Pages

▼

Thursday, November 12, 2026

An Academic Investigation on the Death of Hazrat Fatema Zahra s.a.( Was she Injured? Did she Miscarry Mohsin (a)?) By Shaikh. Agha Mohammadi

 Dr. Agha Mohammadi, in this Part of the academic investigation into the death of Fatima (sa), uses Sunni sources only to discuss the following:

(a) Was Fatima (sa) injured when her house was attacked? (b) Are there Sunni sources that mention Imam 'Ali and Lady Fatima (sa) had 3 sons? (c) Is there any mention in the Sunni sources that the attack on her house led to the miscarriage of Mohsin (a)?


Chapters - ONLY SUNNI SOURCES 00:00 was Fatima (a) injured? 05:00 Authentic Hadith narrators? 08:22 censorship with proof 10:20 Nazzam says Umar did it 12:35 Nazzam labelled kafir 12:54 Who are Ahlul Hadith? 15:25 Ibn Hibban put to death 16:15 Abu Hanifa called kafir 17:09 Bukhari calls Abu Hanifa dajjal 17:31 Ahmad Hanbal hates Abu Hanifa 19:20 Fatima had 3 sons - Ahadith 21:45 Fatima miscarried - Ahadith 23:08 attack led to miscarriage - hadith 23:54 Prophet predicts her broken ribs - hadith 26:36 Censorship - Punishment of such person - Hadith 30:45 Kunfuz caused miscarriage - narration 31:30 "Only ibn Qutayba mentions miscarriage"???!! 35:14 Ibn Taymiyya - Ali (a) & Fatima (sa) hiding people's public money in their house hence Abu Bakr commanded attack on their house!!


يارب محمد عجل فرج آل محمد

 يارب محمد أحفظ غيبة أبنه محمد

 يارب محمـــد أنتقم لأبنه محمـــد



"O Lord of Muhammad! Hasten the reappearance of the progeny of Muhammad. O Lord of Muhammad! Protect the occultation of Muhammad. O Lord of Muhammad! Hasten the revenge of daughter of Muhammad.”