DEBATE: Shia vs Deobandi - Topic Fidak - Audio

Who is the Imam of Fatima Zahra (s.a.)?

So-called Muslims like Ibn Taymiyyah claim that – Allah forbid – Fatima Zahra (s.a.) was wrong in her

claim over Fadak. At any rate, she should not have severed all communication from Abu Bakr and Umar. They were the rulers (haakim) of the time and she should have been cordial with them.

Reply

There is an interesting incident on the subject. At the end, readers can easily conclude whether Fatima Zahra (s.a.) was right or wrong and the message she sent across generations of Muslims by refusing to communicate with Abu Bakr and Umar. Being an infallible, there was complete wisdom in her stand that frustrates Muslims till date when they are called upon to answer the question –

Who is the Imam of Fatima Zahra (s.a.)?

Allamah Amini (r.a.) corners Muslim scholars

Some Saudi Salafi scholars invited Allamah Amini (r.a.) – the author of the Al-Ghadeer, arguably the most decisive book on the event of Ghadeer – for dinner. However Allamah Amini (r.a.) turned down their invitation. They insisted that Allmah Amini (r.a.) accompany them. On insistence, Allmah Amini (r.a.) acceded to their request. However, he put a condition that there would be no discussion or debate over dinner. They agreed. After dinner, a Salafi scholar in the assembly (there were around 70-80 of them) attempted to initiate a discussion. However, Allamah Amini (r.a.) refused to be drawn into a debate.

The debate of Ayatollah Ghazvini with AbdulMajid Muradzehi, regrading the martyrdom of Lady Fatima (sa)

CLICK HERE FOR THE DEBATE BETWEEN AYATULLAH GHAZVINI (SHIA SCHOLAR ) AND ABDUL MAJID MURADZEHI (SUNNI SCHOLAR ) REGARDING THE MARTYDOM OF LADY FATEMAH ZAHRA (SA)


PERSAIN LINK FOR THE SAME DEBATE 

Debate On Fadak Property Of Fatima[AS] - Video PART 19 of 19

This is a series of videos which contains a debate on Fadak - Property Of Janabe Fatima (sa)
It is in 19 parts and in urdu language

 This is part 19 of 19


WATCH THIS VIDEO ON YOUTUBE HERE

Debate On Fadak Property Of Fatima[AS] - Video PART 18 of 19

This is a series of videos which contains a debate on Fadak - Property Of Janabe Fatima (sa)
It is in 19 parts and in urdu language

 This is part 18 of 19


WATCH THIS VIDEO ON YOUTUBE HERE

Debate On Fadak Property Of Fatima[AS] - Video PART 17 of 19

This is a series of videos which contains a debate on Fadak - Property Of Janabe Fatima (sa)
It is in 19 parts and in urdu language

This is part 17 of 19

WATCH THIS VIDEO ON YOUTUBE HERE 

Debate On Fadak Property Of Fatima[AS] - Video PART 16 of 19

This is a series of videos which contains a debate on Fadak - Property Of Janabe Fatima (sa)
It is in 19 parts and in urdu language

This is part 16 of 19


WATCH THIS VIDEO ON YOUTUBE HERE

Debate On Fadak Property Of Fatima[AS] - Video PART 15 of 19

This is a series of videos which contains a debate on Fadak - Property Of Janabe Fatima (sa)
It is in 19 parts and in urdu language

This is part 15 of 19

WATCH THIS VIDEO ON YOUTUBE HERE 

Debate On Fadak Property Of Fatima[AS] - Video PART 14 of 19

This is a series of videos which contains a debate on Fadak - Property Of Janabe Fatima (sa)
It is in 19 parts and in urdu language

This is part 14 of 19


WATCH THIS VIDEO HERE ON YOUTUBE

Debate On Fadak Property Of Fatima[AS] - Video PART 13 of 19

This is a series of videos which contains a debate on Fadak - Property Of Janabe Fatima (sa) 
It is in 19 parts and in urdu language

This is part 13 of 19

WATCH THIS VIDEO ON YOUTUBE HERE 

Debate On Fadak Property Of Fatima[AS] - Video PART 12 of 19

This is a series of videos which contains a debate on Fadak - Property Of Janabe Fatima (sa) 
It is in 19 parts and in urdu language

This is part 12 of 19

WATCH THIS VIDEO ON YOUTUBE HERE 

Debate On Fadak Property Of Fatima[AS] - Video PART 11 of 19

This is a series of videos which contains a debate on Fadak - Property Of Janabe Fatima (sa) 
It is in 19 parts and in urdu language

This is part 11 of 19

CLICK HERE TO WATCH THIS VIDEO ON YOUTUBE 

Debate On Fadak Property Of Fatima[AS] - Video PART 10 of 19

This is a series of videos which contains a debate on Fadak - Property Of Janabe Fatima (sa) 
It is in 19 parts and in urdu language

This is part 10 of 19


WATCH THIS VIDEO ON YOU TUBE HERE 

Debate On Fadak Property Of Fatima[AS] - Video PART 9 of 19

This is a series of videos which contains a debate on Fadak - Property Of Janabe Fatima (sa) 
It is in 19 parts and in urdu language

This is part 9 of 19


CLICK HERE TO WATCH THE VIDEO

Debate On Fadak Property Of Fatima[AS] - Video PART 8

This is a series of videos which contains a debate on Fadak - Property Of Janabe Fatima (sa) 
It is in 19 parts and in urdu language

This is part 8 of 19


CLICK HERE TO WATCH THIS VIDEO ON YOU TUBE