An Academic Investigation on the Death of Hazrat Fatema Zahra s.a.( Threat + Attack on her House - Who was Involved?) By Shaikh. Agha Mohammadi

 Dr. Agha Mohammadi, in this Part of the academic investigation into the death of Fatima (sa), uses Sunni sources only to discuss the threat as well as attack on the house of Fatima (sa). He discusses the clear ahadith as well as the censored hadith (all screenshots provided). This is a long discussion, broken into several sections for the viewer’s ease of understanding.

To those of you, who were waiting for this part and kept inquiring about it, we appreciate your enthusiasm and patience and kind feedback. It motivates us to work harder. May Allah help this Ummah be united despite the differences. We will strive to respectfully investigate this subject that we know might be difficult and painful for some members of the Ummah. We commend your search for factual, evidence-based study.

An Academic Investigation on the Death of Hazrat Fatema Zahra s.a.( Was she Injured? Did she Miscarry Mohsin (a)?) By Shaikh. Agha Mohammadi

 Dr. Agha Mohammadi, in this Part of the academic investigation into the death of Fatima (sa), uses Sunni sources only to discuss the following:

(a) Was Fatima (sa) injured when her house was attacked? (b) Are there Sunni sources that mention Imam 'Ali and Lady Fatima (sa) had 3 sons? (c) Is there any mention in the Sunni sources that the attack on her house led to the miscarriage of Mohsin (a)?

An Academic Investigation on the Death of Hazrat Fatema Zahra s.a. ( Conflict Between Khulafa & Ahl al-Bayt (‘a)) - By Shaikh. Agha Mohammadi

 

• Dr. Agha Mohammadi, in this Part of the academic investigation into the death of Fatima (sa), uses Sunni sources (mainly Sahih Bukhari) to highlight the conflict between the Khulafa and the Ahl al-Bayt ('a) after the death of Prophet Muhammad (s) until the death of Fatima (sa) - all hadith screen shots included. Unlike how Sunni portray it, the conflict was not just about Fadak and then Imam ‘Ali (‘a) reconciled with Abu Bakr.

An Academic Investigation on the Death of Hazrat Fatema Zahra s.a. Part I - Shaikh. Agha Mohammadi

This is a new multi-part series by Shaikh Agha Mohammadi's academic investigation on the Death of Fatima Zahra (sa) from Sunni and Shi'a sources

PART I

CLICK HERE TO WATCH ON YOUTUBE

Martyrdom of Lady Fatima Zahra (sa) - Early Shia Sources

 The proofs for the attack on the house of Lady Fatima (sa) and her resulting martyrdom from Sunni Sources are available and proved .

Now we will look into the same topic from Shi'a Sources. ": Do we have any authentic early Shi'a sources (pre-5th century) that prove Lady Fatima (sa) was attacked, miscarried and was martyred? (All 50+ text references are listed on the screen). By: Shaykh Dr. Morteza Aghamohammadi proving the following points :

Historical Cumulative Proofs not Single Report Early Shia Sources - Threat from AbuBakr/ Umar Early Shia Sources - Attack/ Burning House Early Shia Sources - Beating Fatima (sa) Early Shia Sources - Fatima (sa) Miscarried Child Early Shia Sources - Martyrdom of Lady Fatima (sa) Total 50+ Early Shia Sources (Pre-5th Century) Conceptual Mass Transmission - Mutawatir Ma'anawi

يارب محمد عجل فرج آل محمد

 يارب محمد أحفظ غيبة أبنه محمد

 يارب محمـــد أنتقم لأبنه محمـــد

"O Lord of Muhammad! Hasten the reappearance of the progeny of Muhammad. O Lord of Muhammad! Protect the occultation of Muhammad. O Lord of Muhammad! Hasten the revenge of daughter of Muhammad.”

5th Objection: Why did Hazrat Ali name three of his sons as Abu Bakr, Umar and Usman?

 Reply

• “Umar” was a fairly common and acceptable name amongst the Arabs. This name is not limited only for “Umar ibn Khattab”. By referring to the books of “Rejal” and their translations, we find that many individuals had this name. Thus, Ibn Hajar Asqalaani has listed the names of 22 individuals among the companions of Holy Prophet (s.a.w.a) whose name was “Umar”. Noteworthy among them was Umar bin Abi Salmah Makhzumi (who was the stepson of Holy Prophet (s.a.w.a) and a staunch supporter of H. Ali (a.s))

• In the light of historical evidences, H. Ali (a.s) was not involved in the naming of this particular son. It was Umar ibn Khattab – due to his position and influence – who interfered in the naming of this child and gave him his own name. Ahmed bin Yahya Belazari (d: 279 AH) writes about this and says, “Umar bin Khattab named the son of Ali as “Umar” (Ansab-ul- Ashraaf, vol 2 pg 192)

4th Objection : During his own reign of Khilafat, why didn't Hazrat Ali take steps to avenge the killing of his wife by Umar?

 Reply

• Firstly, do we have all historical details of the life of Ameerul Momineen (a.s)?

• Have the sons of Umar (la) mentioned the killing of their father by Abu Lulu in their entire life time?

• After the burial of J. Zahra (s.a), Ameerul Momineen (a.s) lamented before Holy Prophet (s.a.w.a) and said “….. From tonight my sorrow is eternal and my nights will be sleepless. Till the day when Allah too calls me near you” (Nahjul Balagha, Sermon 202, pg 422, 423; al-Kafi vol 1 pg 459)

• There is a hadees from Sulaym bin Qais which is narrated from H. Ali (a.s) and which is mostly from the time of his (as) reign as caliph. Sulaym says, “I asked H. Ali (a.s) about the atrocities and crimes of Umar. He (as) said, ‘Do you know why Umar would not punish & penalise, Qunfooz, like he punished his other slaves?’ I said ‘No’. He (a.s) said, ‘When Fatima stood between me and the boisterous crowd that had gathered at the door, the one who had whipped her ruthlessly was Qunfooz. The impact and mark of that lashing was so severe that it remained upon Fatima till she left this world. Thus, due to his cooperation and obedience, Umar never punished Qunfooz like his other slaves” (Kitab Sulaym pg 674, H no 30)