WHY WE CHOOSE THIS TOPIC ?




The aim of this blog is to remove whatever doubts that may have entered some people’s minds regarding denial of any violence against Hazrat Fatima Zahra (s.a.) at her home, or against Hazrat Ali (a.s.) at the house of Janabe Fatima Zahra(s.a.).
Authentic references have been provided in the fond hope of a definitive conclusion and the eradication of all doubts Inshallah.



Search This Blog

Saturday, November 14, 2026

25 Early Shia books which believe in the attack on the house of Hazrat Fatima (s.a.) - Part V

 Continued from part IV


21. Al-Shafi fi l-Imamah (d.436H)

  1. Ibraheem ibn Sa'eed Al-Thaqafi (the author of Al-Gharaat who died 283H) says: Narrated Ahmad ibn Amr Al-Bajali from Ahmad ibn Habib Al-Amiri from Humran ibn Ayun from Abi Abdullah Ja'far ibn Muhammad (a.s) who said: "By Allah (swt)! Alee (a.s) did not give a pledge of allegiance until he saw the smoke entered his house."[1]

22. Kanz al-fawa'id (d.449H)

Within a long narration with a sahih chain (Based on a popular opinion) Sheikh Karajaki narrates

  1. …O Yunus, my grandfather the Messenger of Allah said, 'Cursed is the person, cursed is he who oppresses my daughter Fatima after me and takes her right and murders her.' He then said: 'O Fatima, glad tidings for you, for there is a high rank for you in front of Allah, you will intercede with that position for those who love you and for your Shia and Allah will accept your intercession. O Fatima, if every Prophet(عليهم السلام) that Allah has sent and every Angel that Allah has given a high rank intercede for every person who hates you, who has usurped your right, Allah will never take him out of the Hellfire….[2]

23. Amali al-Tusi (d.460H)

  1. With a reliable chain to ‘Ikrimah: Narrated Ibn Abbas that the Prophet (sawa) said:
    “I cry for my descendants and what the evil ones of my Ummah will do to them after me, it is as if I see Fatima, my daughter, and she is being oppressed after me while she is calling “ O’my Father” and none from my Ummah comes to her aid”[3]

 

  1. It is informed to us by Muhammad Bin Ahmad Bin Shazan, from Muhammad Bin Ali Bin Al Mufaddal, from Muhammad Bin Ali Bin Ma’mar, from Muhammad Bin Al Husayn Al Zayyat, from Ahmad Bin Muhammad, from Aban Bin Usman, from Aban Bin Taghlib, ‘From Ja’far Bin Muhammad having said: ‘When (Syeda) Fatima left from the presence of Abu Bakr, she met Amir Al-Momineen. She said to him in prose: ‘O son of Abu Talib! I had gathered the unborn baby, and I have sat down in a room of the lowly, broken in front of the intensely disputing one, so he betrayed you of even the small weapon.This Ibn Quhafa usurped me of an estate of my father, and killed my son (Mohsin). By Allah! He has exerted in oppressing me, and has been bitter in disputing me until he prevented me a little victory, while the Emigrants helped it, and the congregation closed its eyes from me. So he was neither repelled nor prevented (and) by Allah, I had gone out bravely and came back coerced, and alas, If only there had been no choice for me! Alas If only I had died before that, dying before my humiliation, and passed away before my being refused! My excuse from you is Allah usually, and from you is protection. Waah regarding every direction! Waah! The pillar of support has died and the arm (support) is weakened. My complaint is to my Lord and my running is to my father.O Allah! You are of severe strength!’ Amir Al-Momineen answered her: ‘There is no woe for you, but the doom is for your adversaries. I am prevented from your setting, O daughter of the elite,and remainder of the Prophet-hood. By Allah! I am not weak in my Religion, nor am I mistaken of my abilities (power). So, if your calamity is the necessities of life, then your sustenance is guaranteed, and your dependants are secure, and what Allah has Prepared for you is better than what has been cut off from you, so anticipate’.She said: ‘Allah is Sufficient for me and He is the best Guarantor’’.[4]

24. Talkhees Al-Shafi (d.460H)

  1. Narrated Ibraheem ibn Sa'eed Al-Thaqafi from Ahmad ibn Amr Al-Bajali from Ahmad ibn Habib Al-Amiri from Himran ibn Ayun from Abu Abdullah Ja'far ibn Muhammad who said: "By Allah (swt)! Alii (a.s) did not pay allegiance till he saw smoke had indeed entered his house."[5]

 

25. Dala'il Al-Imamah (post 411H and within 5th century)

As a brief disclaimer, it should be noted that the contents of this book and its author are in dispute. The oldest scholar to mention this book is Ibn Shahrashoob (d. 588H) and Ibn Tawus praised this book to the extent that he entrusted its contents to his son. This book has also not reached us in complete form.

 

  1. “...Abu Ja'far Muhammad ibn Ali ibn Al-Hussain (a.s) from his father from his father from his father from Muhammad ibn Ammar ibn Yassir from his father who said: I heard the Messenger of Allah (saw) saying to Ali (a.s), in the day that he married Fatima (s.a) to him: "O Ali(a.s)! Raise your head towards the sky and look what you see?" He said: "I see adorned female servants, there are gifts with them." The Prophet (saw) said: "They are your servants and the servants of Faatima (s.a) in paradise. Go to your house and do not talk until I come." Then he went and the Prophet (saw) went  to his house and he (saw) ordered me to offer them a perfume. Ammar said; The next day I went to the house of Faatima (s.a) and I had the perfume with me, she said: "O Abal Yaq'dhaan! What is this perfume?" I said: "This is a perfume that your father ordered me to offer to you as a gift.".....Ammar said: "Then she became pregnant with Al-Hassan (a.s), then he was born. Then after fourty days she became pregnant with Al-Hussain (a.s) and then Zaynab (s.a) and Umm Kulthum (s.a) were born and then she became pregnant with Al-Mohsin (a.s) when the Messenger of Allah (saw) passed away, and happened what happened on the day of their attack to her house and taking out his cousin, the Commander of the Faithful (a.s), and because of what she suffered from the man (i.e. Umar), she miscarried the complete baby, and that was the main reason of her illness and death, may blessings of Allah (swt) be upon her.[6]

 

  1. Ja'far ibn Muhammad who said said “Fatima (s.a) was born on the twenty of Jumada'l-Akhira in the forty fifth year from the birth of the Prophet (saw). And she resided in Mecca for eight years and in Madina for ten years. And seventy five days after the death of her father, she passed away on the Tuesday of the third of Jumada'l-Akhira in the eleventh year from the Hijra. And the cause of her death was that Qunfudh, the client of the man (Umar ibn Khattab), pounded her with the nail (the silver or iron thing at the lower end of a scabbard) of the sword by his command. So she miscarried Mohsin (a.s) and became sick from that with a severe illness. And she did not let anyone from those who had hurt her to enter upon her. And two men from the companions of the Prophet (saw) asked Amir ul-Mo'mineen (a.s) to intercede for them. So she responded, and when they entered upon her they said to her: "How are you, O daughter of the Messenger of Allah (saw)?" So she said: "Good, praise be to Allah (swt)." Then she said to them: "Have you not heard the Prophet (saw) saying, "Faatima (s.a) is a piece of my flesh, so whoever has hurt her has hurt me, and whoever has hurt me has hurt Allah (swt)!" They said: 'Yes!' She said: "By Allah (swt)! You have hurt me." So they left her while she was displeased with them (Abu Bakr and Umar).[7]

 

  1. “....from Zakariyya ibn Adam who said: I was in the presence of Imam Al-Ridha (a.s) that Abi Ja'far (Imam Al-Jawad (a.s)) came and he was younger than four years old, he hit his hand to the ground and raised his head towards the sky, thinking, then Al-Ridha (a.s) said to him: "May I be your ransom, why you thought for so long?" He (a.s) replied: "I was thinking about what was done to my mother Faatima (s.a). By Allah (swt)! I will take both of them out (i.e. Aboo Bakr and Umar) and I will burn them and then I will disperse them and will leave their ashes to the wind." Imam Al-Ridha (a.s) called him to himself and kissed his forehead and said: "May my father and mother be your ransom" and then said: "You are the one for it" i.e. being the next Imam.[8]

 

  1. “…Al-Hassan ibn Bashir from Abul Jarood from Abi Ja'far who was asked, when will your Qa'im (a.s) rise? He said..."then he will bring out Abu Bakr and Umar, curse of Allah (swt) be upon them both, in a state that their bodies are fresh, then he will talk to them and they will reply, as a result the people of doubt will be confused and they will say that he talks with the death, so he will kill five hundred of them in the Masjid and then he will burn those two with the same firewood that they gathered to burn Ali(a.s), Faatima (s.a), Al-Hasan (a.s) and Al-Hussain (a.s) with it, the remaining of that firewood is with us and we inherit it one from the other."[9]

26. Ihtijaj (d.548H)

This Tabarasi where he omitted the chains. However, a good amount of the contents of the book can be found in other sources. The following narration cannot be found in early works but because of the track record in terms of quoting early books, we have decided to add this to the list.

 

  1. “It is narrated from al-Sha’bi, Abu Mikhnaf, Yazid ibn Habib al-Misri the tradition of Imam al-Hassan al-Mujtaba (as) in which he argued with ‘Amr ibn al-’As, al-Walid ibn ‘Uqbah, ‘Amr ibn ‘Othman and ‘Utbah ibn Abu Sufyan in the presence of Mu’awiyah, and it is quite a lengthy tradition. In it, the Imam (as) says to al-Mughirah ibn Shu’bah, “You are the one who hit Fatima (sa) daughter of the Messenger of Allah, causing her to bleed and she miscarried, thus humiliating the Messenger of Allah, disobeying his order and violating his sanctity since the Messenger of Allah had said to her, ‘O Fatima! You are the Head of all the women of Paradise….” [10]