WHY WE CHOOSE THIS TOPIC ?




The aim of this blog is to remove whatever doubts that may have entered some people’s minds regarding denial of any violence against Hazrat Fatima Zahra (s.a.) at her home, or against Hazrat Ali (a.s.) at the house of Janabe Fatima Zahra(s.a.).
Authentic references have been provided in the fond hope of a definitive conclusion and the eradication of all doubts Inshallah.



Search This Blog

Saturday, November 14, 2026

25 Early Shia books which believe in the attack on the house of Hazrat Fatima (s.a.) - Part IV

 continued from part III


16. Kamil al-Ziyarat (d.386H)

  1. “...  The Prophet (s.a.a.w.) replied, “I have accepted, O Lord. And I am pleased (with Your Will), and I seek success and patience with You.” He was told: As for your daughter, she will be oppressed and deprived, and the rights which you gave her will be usurped. She will be beaten while she is pregnant, her sanctity will be breached, and her house will be entered without permission. Then she will be humiliated and disrespected. She will find no protector, she will suffer from a miscarriage because she will be beaten, and she will die as a result of that beating …The first judgment will be between Muĥsin ibn ‘Ali (a.s.) and his killer…”[1]

 

  1. “ … the killer of Fāťimah and Muĥsin (a.s.) ..”[2]

17. Nahjul Balagha (d.406H)

  1. “.....You have said that I was dragged like a camel with a nose string to swear allegiance (to Abu Bakr at Saqifah). By the Eternal Allah, you had intended to reveal me but you have praised me, and to humiliate me but have yourself been humiliated. What humiliation does it mean for a Muslim to be the victim of oppression so long as he does not entertain any doubt in his religion, nor any misgiving in his firm belief! This argument of mine is intended for others, but I have stated it to you only insofar as it was appropriate…..”[3]

 

This letter is in response to Muwiyah’s letter that can be found in Sharh Nahjul Balagha of Ibn Abil Hadeed Al Mutazali (d.650)[4]

18. Amali al-Mufid (d.413H)

  1. “He said: Abu Bakr Muhammad ibn Umar al-Ji’abi reported to me from Abu al-Husayn al-Abbas ibn al-Mughairah, who reported from Abu Bakr Ahmad ibn Mansoor al-Ramadi, who reported from Saeed ibn Ufayr who reported from Ibn Lah’eah, from Khalid ibn Yazeed, from Ibn Abi Hilal, from Marwan ibn Uthman who said: When people swore the allegiance on the hands of Abu Bakr, ‘Ali (as), al-Zubair and al-Miqdad entered the house of Fatimah, peace be upon her, and refused to come out. So, Umar ibn al-Khattab said: "Set the house on fire upon them." Then al-Zubair came out with his sword. So Abu Bakr said: "Catch this dog." As they advanced towards him, he (al-Zubair) slipped and fell and the sword fell off his hand. Then Abu Bakr said: "Hit him with the stone." Zubair hit the stone till it broke. ‘Ali ibn Abi Talib (as) left the house from the direction of Aaliyah and met Thabit ibn Qays ibn Shammas. He said: "O Abul Hasan, what has happened to you?" He said: "They have resolved on burning down my house, while Abu Bakr is sitting on the pulpit, receiving allegiance, he neither prevents them from doing it nor is he condemning it." Thabit said: "My palm will not leave your hand, till I am killed by your side." So they moved forward together till they came back towards Madinah while Fatimah (peace be upon her) stood at her door, and all of the people had left her house. She was saying: "I have not known of an assembly of people worse than you; you left the messenger of Allah unattended, when his corpse lay before us; you resolved about your affairs among yourselves, refusing to seek our leadership; and you did to us what you did, and you recognized no right for us."”[5]

 

  1. Sayyida Fatima in a long elegy in front of Rasulullah's grave says the following “....Men have attacked us and humiliated us, after the Prophet, and all wealth has been usurped; The perpetrator of injustices to us will know his fate on the day of Judgement, where he will finally land. We have come across things which no one before us, neither from Arabs nor from the Ajam have suffered; So, we shall continue weeping over you as long as we live, and as long as we have eyes which well up with flowing tears."[6]

19. Kitab Al-Jamal (d.413H)

Sheikh Al Mufid accounts in his account of Jamal that

  1. “When the clan of Hashim and others who met in Fatima’s house gathered to keep away from Abu Bakr and show their public opposition, Umar despatched Qunfudh, telling him: ‘Make those who are in the house come out, if they come out (i.e. that will be alright). If they do not, then collect firewood around the door and tell them that if they do not come out to make the pledge of allegiance, I will set fire to the house with them in it. Then Umar led a group including Al-Mughira Ibn Shubaha Al Thaqafi and Salim, the retainer of Hudhayfa, until they came to Ali’s door. He called out; ‘O Fatima daughter of the Messenger of God! Bring out those who are seeking protection in your house so that they may make a pledge of allegiance and enter into (agreement) which the people have entered. Otherwise by God, I will set fire to the house with them in it.”[7]

20. Al-Ikhtisas (Early 5th Hijri)

Please note that this book is attributed to Sheikh Mufid but the authorship is disputed.

 

  1. Aboo Muhammad, narrating from Amr ibn Abil Miqdam, from his father, from his grandfather who said: No greater days had come to Alee (a.s) than two specific days. The first one is the day God made the Prophet (saw) demise and the second day, by Allah (swt) I say that I was sitting at the Saqifah of Bani Sa'ida to the right of Aboo Bakr and people giving him allegiance then Umar told him, "O you! You have achieved nothing until Alee (a.s) does not give you allegiance. Therefore send after him so that he comes to you and gives you allegiance." He said; then he sent Qunfudh, and he told him [told Alee (a.s)], "Answer the call of the caliphate of the Messenger of Allah (saw). Alee (a.s) said, "[It is surprising] how fast you lied upon the Messenger of Allah (saw), the Messenger of Allah (saw) did not appoint anyone as a successor but me!" Then Qunfudh came back and told Aboo Bakr the saying of Alee (a.s) then Aboo Bakr said, "Go to him and tell him; Aboo Bakr calls for you and says, 'Come to give allegiance because you are one man amongst Muslims." Alee (a.s) said, "The Messenger of Allah (saw) ordered me not to go out of my house after him till I complete the Book, since it is in palm branches (stripped of leaves) and camels epaulet [leather]." Then Qunfudh came to him [Aboo Bakr] and told him the saying of Alee (a.s). Then Umar said, "Let us go to this man." So Aboo Bakr and Umar and Uthman and Khalid ibn Al-Walid and Al-Mughira ibn Shu'ba and Aboo Ubaydah ibn Al-Jarrah and Salim the servant of Abi Hudhayfah and I went with them, and Faatima (s.a) thought that they would not enter her house without her permission. Then she pulled the door and closed it, and when they reached the door, Umar kicked the door with his leg and broke it – and the door was made from palm leaves and branches, fronds- and they entered to Alee (a.s) and took him out surrounded and dragged him holding his garment. Then Faatima (s.a) came out and said, "O Aboo Bakr and Umar! You want to make me widowed? By Allah (swt)! I say that if you don't let him go then I would spread my hair and cut my shirt collar and go to my father's grave and call my Lord." Then she went out and took the hands of Al-Hassan (a.s) and Al-Hussain (a.s) heading towards the grave. Then Alee (a.s) told Salman, "O Salman! Go after the daughter of Muhammad (saw), because I am seeing the two sides of Al-Madinah bending, and by Allah (swt)! If she does what she said, then there would be no time delay before Al-Madinah and its people would be buried under the ground." He said; then Salman went after her and said, "O daughter of Muhammad (saw)! Allah t(swt) he most blessed and high sent your father as mercy, so do not do this." Then she said, "O Salman! I can't be patient then let me till I reach my father's grave and I call my Lord." Salman said, "Alee (a.s) sent me after you and ordered you to go back." Then she said, "I listen to him and I obey." And she went back, and they took Alee (a.s) surrounded and dragged him out. He said, Then Al-Zubayr came carrying his sword while saying, "O you folk of Bani Abdul Muttalib! [How can] you accept this to be done to Alee (a.s) and you are alive!" And he headed towards Umar to hit him by his sword then Khalid ibn Al-Walid hit him by a rock that hit his back and the sword fell out of his hand, then Umar took it and hit it on a rock so it broke and then when Alee (a.s) passed by the grave of the Prophet (saw) he said, "O son of my mother! Indeed the people judged me weak and were about to kill me" {7:150}. Alee (a.s) was taken to Saqifah to the place where Aboo Bakr sat then Umar told him, "Give allegiance." He (a.s) said, "And if I don't then what would you do?" He said, "Then by Allah (swt) we will chop your head off." Then Alee (a.s) said, "Then by Allah (swt)! I would be the murdered slave of Allah (swt) and brother of the Messenger of Allah (saw)." Then Umar said, "Yes, the murdered slave of Allah (swt), but not the brother of the Messenger of Allah (saw)." And he said it thrice - then Al-Abbas came and said, "O Aboo Bakr! Be gentle to my nephew and I guarantee you that he will give you allegiance." Then Al-Abbas took Alee's (a.s) hand [peace be upon him] and he made it touch Aoo Bakr's hand and they let Alee (a.s) go angry, looking to the sky and he said, "O Allah (swt)! Verily You know that the Ummi Prophet (saw) told me, 'If there were twenty supporters for you then fight against them' and it is Your saying in your Book; 'If there are twenty steadfast persons amongst you, they will overcome two hundred' {8:65}. "O Allah (swt)! They [supporters] were not complete!" [the recommended number] – till he said it thrice - then he left.[8]

 

  1. He (i.e. Ahmad ibn Muhammad ibn Isa) narrated from his father and from Al-Abbas ibn Ma'rouf from Abdullah ibn Al-Mughira who said: narrated to me Abdullah ibn Abdul Rahman Al-Asam from Abdullah ibn Bikr Al-Irjaani who said: I accompanied Aba Abdullah (a.s) from Madinah to Makkah. On our journey, we stopped in an area called Usfan and passed by a black, frightening mountain to the left of the road. I said, "O son of Allah's Messenger (saw)! How frightening this mountain is! I have never seen a more frightening mountain like this on our route.''Imam (a.s) asked, "Ibn Bukair! Do you know which mountain it is?" I replied, "No." Imam (a.s) said: "This is a mountain called Kamad, and it overlooks a valley of Hell which contains the killers of my father, Hussain ibn Alee (a.s). Liquids of Hell flow under the killers of my father (in this valley). These liquids include Ghislin, Sadid, Hamim. That which emerges from the Putrid Well, that which comes out from the clay of Khabal (pus), that which comes out from Jahannam (Hell), that which comes out from Hutamah, that which comes out from Saqar, that which comes out from Hamim, that which comes out from Hawiya and that which comes out from Sa'ir. Every time I pass by this mountain on my journey, I stop and see those two (i.e. Aboo Bakr and Umar) seeking refuge with me, and I look at the killers of my ancestors (a.s) and I say to those two: 'Indeed these have done what they did because of what you two established the foundations of that. You showed us no mercy at the time of reign. You killed us, denied and usurped our rights and tyrannized our affairs by deposing us. May Allah (swt) not have mercy on those who have mercy on you two. Now taste the evil result of that which you brought forth, because Allah (swt) is not unjust to any of His servants.' Sometimes I stand there to soothe some of that which is in my heart, and the second (i.e Umar) one begs and succumbs to despair more intensely." I asked, "May I be sacrificed for you! What do you hear when you climb this mountain?" Imam (a.s) replied: "I hear the voices of those two (Aboo Bakr and Umar). They call out, 'Come to us so that we can talk, indeed we repent.' And (then) I hear a call from the mountain which cries out, 'Answer them and tell them, remain condemned in it and speak not to me {23:108}.'"I asked, "May I be sacrificed for you! Who else is with them?" Imam (a.s) replied, "Every tyrant of Pharaoh, whose actions Allah (swt) has mentioned and everyone who taught disbelief to the servants of Allah (swt)." I asked, "Who are they?"Imam (a.s) replied: "The likes of Quras, who taught the Jews that Uzayr is the son of Allah (swt), and the likes of Nastur who taught the Christians that...Isa Al-Messiah is the son of Allah (swt) {9:30}' and who told them that they are three; the likes of Pharaoh (at the time) of Musa (a.s) who said, I am your Lord, the Most High {79:24}'; and the likes of Nimrud who said, 'I have overpowered everyone on Earth and I have killed those in the heavens'; and the killer of Amir ul Mo'mineen (a.s), the killer of Faatima (s.a) and Mohsin (a.s) and the killers of Hassan (a.s) and Hussain (a.s); and also Mu'awiyah and Amr ibn Aas, who have no hope of being saved and anyone who incited animosity against us and helped (our enemies) with his tongue, wealth or hand against us will also be with them." I asked, "where does this mountain end?" He said: "To the sixth layer of the Earth and there locates the fire and that is one of its valleys, over which the angels are the guardians more than the number of the stars of the sky and drops of rain and drops of water of oceans and the number of dust particles and Allah (swt) has given to everyone of them a job that he is busy with it and does not leave it."[9]