This is what Hazrat Fatema, peace be upon her, said when they wanted to takeFadak from her:
“O’ People, haven’t you heard from the Prophet, peace be upon him and his family, that
he said: Indeed, my daughter Fatima is the Chief Mistress of Women in Paradise?’
They said: ‘By God, yes. We have heard that from the Prophet, peace be upon him and
his family.’
She said: ‘Then is it logical for the Chief Mistress of Women in Paradise to claim
something which is false and doesn’t belong to her?! If four people bear witnessed that I
committed an obscenity or two people claimed I stole, would you believe them over me?’
Abu Bakr stayed silent, Umar responded: ‘Yes, and we would apply the appropriate
punishment.’
She said: ‘You liar! If you do so, then you are on a religion other than the religion of
Muhammad, peace be upon him and his family. If someone asks the Chief Mistress of
Women in Paradise for witnesses or tries to apply punishment on her is an accursed
individual, a disbeliever in what Allah has sent down upon Muhammad, peace be upon
him and his family. Those whom Allah has protected them from impurity and purified
them a thorough purification are not needed to be asked for witnesses, because they are
infallible from every error, purified from every sin. Tell me O’ Umar about this verse. If a
group of people witnessed that those individuals referred to in that verse committed
polytheism, or disbelief, or obscenity; would the Muslims disassociate from them and
apply punishment?’
Umar said: ‘Yes, they and the rest of the people are equal.’
She said: ‘You liar and disbeliever! How are they equal to the rest of the people? Those
individuals referred in that verse were purified by God and made infallible. Whomever
provides a testimony against them, has attributed lies to Allah and His Prophet.”
Fatimat al-Zahraa Bahjat Qalb al-Mustafa, page 307
